Ready to Get Started?
Our building materials specialists can help you find the right products for your project.
Browse › Building Materials
Fiberglass vs. Cellulose, R-Value and How Many Bags
Building MaterialsA cold upstairs bedroom, frost on the inside of the attic hatch, icicles hanging off the eaves: that’s usually heat going up through the ceiling. Blown-in insulation is one of the most straightforward fixes there is. Loose insulation blown across the attic floor makes one continuous blanket over the joists and around wires, pipes and framing, with none of the gaps you get fitting batts around obstacles.
“Blown-in” is how it goes in, not what it is. The two common materials:
Either one does the job in an open attic when it goes in at the right depth. Pick by what’s already up there and what you’d rather work with.
| Product | Coverage per bag |
|---|---|
| JM Climate Pro B-7700 fiberglass blowing wool | 77 sq ft at R-30 |
| Blown-in insulation | 73 sq ft at R-30 |
That coverage number is the one that matters. It tells you how much attic one bag covers at a given R-value when it’s blown to the depth on the bag’s chart.
R-value is resistance to heat flow; the higher, the better a layer holds heat in. How much you need depends mostly on climate, and Montana is cold-climate country: energy-efficiency guidance for climates like ours commonly recommends R-49 to R-60 in an attic. Your local code sets the minimum for new work; for an upgrade, R-49 or more is a sensible goal.
To figure bags:
At R-30, a 1,000-square-foot attic takes about 13 bags of Climate Pro (1,000 ÷ 77) or 14 of the 73-square-foot bags. For a higher R-value, the chart on the bag gives a smaller coverage per bag, so you’ll need more.
Two things to watch. Blow to the depth on the chart, not by eye. Loose fill settles a little, and the charts already allow for it; if you stretch the bags over more area, you get a thin layer and cold spots. Count your existing insulation. Dry, clean old insulation can stay, and you only buy for the R-value you’re adding. If there’s roughly R-19 of old insulation up there and you’re going to R-49, figure bags for about R-30, not R-49.
Insulation slows heat; it doesn’t stop air. Warm air leaking into the attic through gaps carries heat and moisture with it, and neither fiberglass nor cellulose seals those gaps. Do these first:
In Kootenai country, especially around Libby, pre-1990 homes may have vermiculite insulation that can contain asbestos. It’s pebbly, gray-brown or silvery. If you find it, leave it alone and have it assessed before anyone works in that attic.
Closed walls in an older house can be filled through holes drilled in each cavity, most often with dense-packed cellulose. That’s a different job from blowing an attic, packed much tighter, and worth planning carefully, including making sure water isn’t getting into those walls.
For an attic top-up, JM Climate Pro fiberglass blowing wool or the 73-square-foot-per-bag blown-in insulation, enough bags for your attic’s area at your target R-value from the bag chart. Seal the air leaks and set the baffles first.
How many bags of blown-in insulation do I need?
Divide your attic floor area by the coverage per bag at the R-value you’re adding, from the bag’s chart, and round up. At R-30, a 1,000-square-foot attic takes about 13 bags of Climate Pro.
Is fiberglass or cellulose better?
Both work in an open attic at the right depth. Fiberglass is lighter and less dusty; cellulose is denser and is the one used to dense-pack closed walls.
Can I blow new insulation over old?
Usually, if the old insulation is dry, clean and not crushed. Fix leaks and moisture first.
Do I need to air seal before insulating?
Yes. Insulation doesn’t stop air, and air leaks carry heat and moisture into the attic. Seal the holes first.
How is blown-in different from spray foam?
Blown-in is loose fiber laid across the attic floor. Spray foam is sprayed on as a liquid and expands into a solid layer that also seals air. They’re different products and different jobs.
Our building materials specialists can help you find the right products for your project.